Key Points – Michigan Democratic Representative Shri Thanedar announced Tuesday his intent to force a House vote on the seven articles of impeachment he filed against President Trump in late April, utilizing a “question of privilege.”
-This procedural move will likely compel House Republicans to quickly table or kill the resolution.
-However, it will also force all Democrats to take a public stance on impeachment, a vote many in competitive districts would prefer to avoid.
-Thanedar’s action, taken without endorsement from Democratic leadership, has reportedly drawn significant criticism from within his own party, with some viewing it as a selfish distraction.
The Donald Trump Impeachment Challenge
Ever since Rep. Shri Thanedar (D-MI) introduced articles of impeachment for President Trump in late April, the move has been frequently described as a “long-shot” impeachment, which has no real hope of moving forward as long as Republicans remain in control of Congress.
Now, the Congressman has announced that he is going to force a vote on the impeachment question.
Thanedar on Tuesday said he has “notified the Chair of his intent to offer a question of the privileges of the House to force a vote on the Impeachment of Donald J Trump.”
The seven articles of impeachment include “obstruction of justice and abuse of executive power,” “seizing Congress’ power of the purse,” “abuse of trade powers and international aggression,” “violation of First Amendment rights,” “creation of an unlawful office,” “bribery and corruption,” and “tyrannical overreach.”
“As a member of Congress, I have a responsibility to uphold the checks and balances that safeguard the integrity of our democracy, and right now those checks are being eroded by a president who feels he is above the law,” the Congressman said. “This must be a red line. We cannot stand by regardless of whether we have the votes on the other side of the aisle. It’s never the wrong time to stand up for our Constitution.”
What Now?
As Axios characterized the move, Thanedar has “started the clock for the House to vote” on the measure. This will likely lead House Republicans to move to table or kill the measure.
The next step after that will lead to a vote on the tabling, which, per Axios, will have the effect of “forcing Democrats into a tough position on a vote many of them would rather not take.”
The House Democratic leadership has not endorsed Thanedar’s impeachment quest, and several Congressmen have pulled out of being cosponsors of the impeachment resolution. Axios presented that as Thanedar “listing several colleagues as co-sponsors on his impeachment articles based on vague conversations without looping in their staffs.”
Thanedar told Axios that he has had “some communication” with the party’s leadership, but that “I didn’t seek permission, I just communicated.”
Democratic Unhappiness
A separate Axios story showed that many Democrats in the House caucus aren’t happy with Thanedar about forcing the vote, although most of them did not go on the record with their names.
“It’s going to cause Democrats in [competitive] seats to make tough decisions,” a Democratic Congressman told Axios. The idea is that some members of Congress will have difficulty running in areas that Trump won if they voted for impeachment.
Other Congressmen indicated that they believe Thanedar is only pushing impeachment to try to stave off a pair of primary challenges in his Michigan district.
There was some cursing, too.
The one Congressman quoted by name in the story, Rep. Brad Schneider (D-IL), said that the impeachment effort was a distraction from the current negotiations over the budget and Trump’s “Big Beautiful Bill,” which will likely give Democrats lots of opportunities for political hay.
A Different Story in 2027?
There are indications, though, that Democrats will be more amenable to impeachment, in the event of a 2026 midterm election victory that puts them in charge of one or both houses of Congress the following January. That’s what happened in 2019, after the Democrats captured the House, although they didn’t pursue impeachment right away.
Sen. Jon Ossoff (D-GA), who is running for re-election in 2026, has indicated that he might be on board with impeachment, should Democrats capture Congress.
Then again, there’s a chance that if impeachment is pursued in the future, it will be concerning some scandal that hasn’t even come to light yet. That said, Democrats are likely not to have a large enough Senate majority to convict Trump.
About the Author
Stephen Silver is an award-winning journalist, essayist and film critic, and contributor to the Philadelphia Inquirer, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency, Broad Street Review and Splice Today. The co-founder of the Philadelphia Film Critics Circle, Stephen lives in suburban Philadelphia with his wife and two sons. For over a decade, Stephen has authored thousands of articles that focus on politics, technology, and the economy. Follow him on X (formerly Twitter) at @StephenSilver, and subscribe to his Substack newsletter.
Trump Really Headed for Impeachment?
Pingback: Action on H.Res.353, Articles for the Impeachment of Donald J Trump due Thursday, May 15, 2025 – Arterutan / On Warrior Kings and Other Things